Why I insist on competence in suicide care
Paul Quinnett, PhD
Back when I was a clinical director responsible for about 450 clinicians of all stripes, training, and backgrounds, I was sometimes called Dr. Marshmallow. I gave people second and third chances, sometimes a fourth. Either they were slow learners or I was.
But after my team and I began trying to prevent our own patients from dying by suicide, I acquired a new name: Hard Ass.
The deaths of patients stay with me. They are not supposed to happen. Part of our job was to make sure they did not happen. I was also responsible for emergency mental health services for roughly half a million people, including our regional responsibilities under Washington’s Involuntary Treatment Act. Our responsibility included identifying people in danger, assessing their need for care, and arranging protection and treatment, including inpatient care when warranted under the law. I hired the best people I could find to do these jobs. I assumed new hires arriving from graduate school knew what they were doing. I was wrong. Too many of the people I was hiring had come through graduate schools, nursing schools, and even PhD programs without adequate preparation to assess and manage suicide risk, let alone treat people who wanted to die by suicide. If our new hires were to learn how to do this, we would have to teach them.
Working with Washington State University and the Washington Institute for Mental Illness Research and Training, we developed a training program and examination of suicide risk assessment and management knowledge and skills. Over many months, we developed ways to evaluate competence. My employees did not like the testing. I don’t think anyone likes to be tested. But my argument was that professional discomfort with an examination should not outweigh the patient’s need for competent care.
QPRT (Suicide Risk Assessment and Management Training Program) is listed as an approved program in the Suicide Prevention Resource Center’s Best Practices Registry.
Over time we grew the program and tested it in other settings. Our historical data summarize results from about 1,100 practicing mental health professionals in 13 states. Using our examination’s threshold of 75 percent correct, roughly 35 percent of psychiatrists passed before training. Fewer than 10 percent of social workers, nurses, and mental health counselors passed. These are findings from the clinicians we tested, not estimates for every member of those professions (QPR Institute, n.d.-b).
A separate multicenter analysis reported average knowledge scores of approximately 53 before instruction and 81 afterward across 28 training centers. These findings showed substantial immediate knowledge gains, not proof of lasting skill or better patient outcomes (Schumacher et al., n.d.). Our credentialing process therefore required more: supervised role-play and review of three actual patient assessments, including safety planning and documentation (QPR Institute, n.d.-a). If you didn’t pass the exam, you had to study harder and take it again. Inadequate documentation of an assessment or treatment plan also had to be corrected. My reputation as a hard ass grew.
My oldest son understood the issue as a teenager facing thyroid surgery. He asked the physician about to operate on his neck, “What kind of grades did you get in surgery?” It was only half funny. Someone seeking care for suicidal thoughts deserves to ask an equally serious question.
For several years I served on Washington’s Board of Examiners for Psychology, including a term as chair. Here is a confession: during my service, our oral examinations did not ask candidates how they would care for a suicidal patient. As I recall, the written examination did not address this competency either. Later, I offered examination questions to help fill the gap. I received no reply.
In 2009, I challenged the field through the American Association of Suicidology listserv. An AAS task force followed, and in 2012 my colleagues and I published its report on serious training deficits (Schmitz et al., 2012). In my 2015 blog, “Waiting for Professor Smith,” I asked where students would find the teachers and supervised clinical experience to prepare them. I am still asking.
My concern is that we have not built a strong enough teaching tradition in this area of practice. We need experienced clinicians preparing students and future teachers. Our training remains available online with an examination, but we stopped preparing instructors to teach it because the process became too complicated and expensive, and interest was limited. Having a curriculum is only the beginning.
I am glad the Joint Commission now explicitly requires training and competence assessment for staff caring for patients at risk of suicide in the settings covered by its standards. I remember recommending this kind of expectation about 25 years ago. Yet in June 2026, it reported finding staff conducting suicide risk assessments without evidence of training or competence. The gap persists even where standards exist (Joint Commission, 2026, n.d.). It seems Sisyphus had it easy.
Those accreditation requirements do not establish a universal suicide care credential for independent private practitioners. A patient cannot assume that every professional license represents an observed demonstration of suicide-specific clinical skill. A license alone does not answer that question.
I worry particularly about master’s-level clinicians entering independent practice with limited preparation in suicide care. Excellent clinicians hold master’s degrees; a doctorate alone does not establish competence either. What matters is what someone has learned and demonstrated.
When a patient dies by suicide, a clinician can become a survivor of that loss, carrying grief and doubt that may alter a career. Rigorous preparation may provide a firmer basis for reviewing what happened: I was trained, my skills were assessed, and I sought consultation. My surgeon friends lose patients, too. At least they can point to rigorous medical training and examinations beyond count. I believe that preparation gives them a foundation of knowledge and confidence when they face a loss. Clinicians providing suicide care deserve that foundation as well. It cannot prevent every death or erase grief, and a patient’s suicide does not by itself establish clinical failure.
Programs that assess knowledge or clinical performance
Quigley, my AI assistant, identified these examples from published program requirements where testing is involved. They assess different skills and confer different designations. This is a selected guide, not a ranking of treatments.
CAMS Certified. Collaborative Assessment and Management of Suicidality addresses the problems driving suicidal thoughts and behavior. Certification adds a textbook test and a two-hour standardized-patient competency review, repeated every five years. Program details
DBT–Linehan Board of Certification. Dialectical behavior therapy addresses life-threatening behavior and teaches coping skills. Certification requires a knowledge examination and review of three consecutive recorded clinical sessions, with at least one meeting adherence standards. This is broader DBT certification. Program details
Penn Safety Planning Intervention. This brief intervention develops a collaborative plan for responding to a suicidal crisis. The competency pathway requires a knowledge test, coached practice, and a standardized-patient examination meeting a specified rating-scale cutoff. Safety planning is one component of care. Program details
Penn Cognitive Therapy for Suicide Prevention. This psychotherapy for adults addresses suicidal thinking and behavior. Extended competency training includes six months of consultation and review of recorded sessions using the Cognitive Therapy Rating Scale. The published description does not specify a final certification cutoff. Program details
To locate clinicians: CAMS directory • DBT-LBC directory
Ask whether a CAMS practitioner is Trained or Certified; these are different levels. For any clinician, ask: “What training have you completed in assessing and treating suicidal patients, and has anyone observed and evaluated you doing that work?” These credentials help guide a search but are not the only evidence of competence. Care must also fit the person’s age and needs.
A trucker must earn a commercial driver’s license, or CDL, through knowledge and skills testing. I want the clinical equivalent of that road test: an observed interview, passing test scores, sound decisions, and review of actual work, with more teaching and supervision when needed. The patient should not be the first person to discover a missing skill (Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, n.d.).
I have been riding this old hobby horse for a long time. I would get off the damn thing if demonstrated competence became a dependable expectation in suicide care. Until then, if insisting on it makes me a hard ass, I can live with that.
Dr. Paul
Download the QPRT Credentialing Companion (editable Word document). It summarizes our earlier process for organizations interested in developing their own updated model. The historical model needs updating and local review before use.
References
CAMS-care. (n.d.). CAMS Certified. Read source
DBT–Linehan Board of Certification. (n.d.). Eligibility requirements. Read source
Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration. (n.d.). How do I get a commercial driver’s license? Read source
Joint Commission. (2026, June). Joint Commission News. See Clinical Improvement Opportunities, Suicide Risk Assessment. Read source
Joint Commission. (n.d.). Resources for suicide risk reduction. Read source
Penn Center for the Prevention of Suicide. (n.d.-a). Training for cognitive therapy for suicide prevention. University of Pennsylvania. Read source
Penn Center for the Prevention of Suicide. (n.d.-b). Training for the safety planning intervention. University of Pennsylvania. Read source
QPR Institute. (n.d.-a). Credential/competency criteria: Core competency—Suicide risk assessment [Historical internal credentialing document].
Quinnett, P. (2009, August). Rant to American Association of Suicidology [Listserv message; author’s copy].
Quinnett, P. (2015, August 5). Waiting for Professor Smith. OnSuicide. Read source
Schmitz, W. M., Jr., Allen, M. H., Feldman, B. N., Gutin, N. J., Jahn, D. R., Kleespies, P. M., Quinnett, P., & Simpson, S. (2012). Preventing suicide through improved training in suicide risk assessment and care: An American Association of Suicidology Task Force report addressing serious gaps in U.S. mental health training. Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior. Read source
Schumacher, M., Gutierrez, P. M., & Quinnett, P. (n.d.). A multi-center study of the effectiveness of an 8-hour suicide risk assessment and risk management course (QPRT) in increasing knowledge about suicide [Unpublished program evaluation].
QPR Institute. (n.d.-b). QPRT pre-post suicide risk assessment training test scores [Historical presentation; author’s copy].
Program requirements checked November 14, 2026. The slides’ rounded sample and passing rates are reported separately from the multicenter report’s mean scores; the two summaries are not assumed to use identical analytic samples.
AI Disclosure
The ideas, opinions, clinical experience, and occasional provocations are mine. Quigley helps me get them onto the page, and I review what we produce before it goes out into the world.